For shoppers searching for the best Rothy’s clogs, the choice comes down to whether you want a versatile platform, a warmer lined footbed, or an easy open-back design. I’d start with The Casual Clog for its lightweight build, cushioned arch support, and indoor-outdoor outsole; choose The Cozy Clog if a soft vegan-shearling lining matters more; and look at The Revelvet Casual Clog for a roomy, simple-to-slip-on shape with a merino wool upper.
Get your wardrobe favorites delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
These models share a casual mule silhouette, but they are not interchangeable. The Casual Clog runs big and calls for sizing down, while The Cozy Clog is roomy and advises people between sizes to size up. The Revelvet’s open back keeps entry easy, but its listed materials and care details are less complete. I’ve ranked them by how clearly their stated features support everyday use, comfort, and practical ownership—not by treating extra softness or easy entry as automatic wins.
Key Takeaways
- I rank The Casual Clog first for its combination of a cushioned, arch-supporting insole, lightweight platform design, washable upper, and traction-bearing rubber outsole.
- The Casual Clog runs big, so its sizing advice differs from The Cozy Clog, which is roomy and recommends sizing up for shoppers between sizes.
- The Cozy Clog is the lineup’s warmth-focused choice, with vegan-shearling lining under a contoured footbed; it is not water resistant.
- The Revelvet Casual Clog prioritizes a roomy fit and open-back convenience, but its polyester-listed sole and outer material set it apart from the two rubber-outsole options.
- All three are slip-on clogs, yet buyers should compare lining, sizing, outsole material, and care instructions instead of choosing by silhouette alone.
| Rothy’s The Casual Clog Women’s Slip-On Mule |  | Best Overall — a lightweight, versatile clog with the clearest everyday feature mix | Style: Platform slip-on mule clog | Upper: Merino wool and thread made from recycled plastic bottles | Insole: Cushioned with arch support | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Rothy’s The Cozy Clog Women’s Slip-On Shoe |  | Best for a Softer Lined Footbed — the lineup’s comfort-focused choice | Style: Women’s pull-on slip-on clog | Upper: Bouclé yarn blended with thread made from recycled plastic bottles | Footbed: Contoured with arch support and vegan-shearling lining | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Rothy’s Women’s The Revelvet Casual Clogs |  | Best for Easy Entry — a roomy open-back clog with a merino wool knit upper | Design: Open-back casual clog | Upper: Knit upper using RWS-certified merino wool | Outer material: Polyester | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Rothy’s clog | Upper | Sole material | Fit | Style |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rothy’s The Casual Clog Women’ | Merino wool and thread made from recycled plastic bottles | Rubber | Runs big; sizing down recommended | Platform slip-on mule clog |
| Rothy’s The Cozy Clog Women’s | Bouclé yarn blended with thread made from recycled plastic bottles | Rubber | Roomy; size up if between sizes | Women’s pull-on slip-on clog |
| Rothy’s Women’s The Revelvet C | Knit upper using RWS-certified merino wool | Polyester | Roomy | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Rothy’s The Casual Clog Women’s Slip-On Mule
Best Overall — a lightweight, versatile clog with the clearest everyday feature mix
View Latest PriceThe Casual Clog takes the top spot because it has the most balanced stated feature set of the three: a lightweight platform shape, cushioned insole with arch support, and rubber outsole described as providing traction for indoor and outdoor use. That makes it the most straightforward pick for someone who wants one slip-on clog to wear around the house and for casual outings, rather than a style chosen chiefly for extra lining or an open back.
Its knit upper combines merino wool with thread made from recycled plastic bottles, and the shoe can be machine washed in cold water. Those details add a useful care and materials angle, but washing does not mean it can go straight into a dryer: the brand calls for air drying without heat. Compared with The Cozy Clog, this model is described as cushioned and lightweight rather than lined with vegan shearling. If you want a noticeably soft lining around the foot, the Cozy is the more relevant alternative.
The main buying hurdle is fit. This clog runs big, and sizing down is recommended, which is the reverse of the Cozy Clog’s guidance for people between sizes. I would pay close attention to that distinction rather than assuming the same Rothy’s size will work across both. The platform design also will not suit everyone seeking a flatter, less substantial-looking shoe. Still, for buyers prioritizing a clear blend of support, traction, washable construction, and everyday flexibility, it is the strongest all-round choice in this lineup.
Pros:- Lightweight platform build with a cushioned insole and arch support.
- Rubber outsole is described as providing traction indoors and outdoors.
- Machine washable in cold water, with an upper that includes thread made from recycled plastic bottles.
- Merino wool knit upper gives it a different material feel from the Cozy’s bouclé and vegan-shearling setup.
Cons:- Runs big, so the brand recommends sizing down.
- Must air dry without heat after washing.
- The platform silhouette may not suit shoppers who want a lower-profile clog.
Best for: Shoppers seeking a lightweight everyday mule with a cushioned, arch-supporting insole and a rubber outsole described for indoor and outdoor traction.
Not ideal for: People who prefer a snug fit without sizing adjustments, need machine-dryer care, or want a shearling-like lining for extra softness.
- Style:Platform slip-on mule clog
- Upper:Merino wool and thread made from recycled plastic bottles
- Insole:Cushioned with arch support
- Sole material:Rubber
- Fit:Runs big; sizing down recommended
- Care:Machine wash cold; air dry without heat
- Origin:Imported
Our verdict“I recommend The Casual Clog as the most versatile pick here, provided its runs-big sizing and air-dry care fit your routine.”
Rothy’s The Cozy Clog Women’s Slip-On Shoe
The Cozy Clog is the pick for shoppers who want a softer-feeling footbed rather than the lighter, more general-purpose setup of The Casual Clog. Its contoured footbed provides arch support and is lined with vegan shearling, while the bouclé knit upper gives the shoe a distinct textured finish. This combination makes it the most clearly comfort- and warmth-oriented model in the group, though the product details do not specify a temperature range or make it suitable for wet conditions.
Like the Casual Clog, the Cozy has a rubber outsole described as offering traction for both indoor and outdoor wear. That shared outsole material means the choice between them is less about the broad use category and more about fit and underfoot feel: the Casual is lightweight and cushioned, whereas the Cozy adds a lined, contoured footbed. The upper uses bouclé yarn blended with thread made from recycled plastic bottles, and the shoe is machine washable. It still needs to air dry, so it is not a quick machine-to-ready option.
Fit advice is a deciding factor here. The Cozy is roomy, and shoppers between sizes are advised to size up. That guidance differs from the Casual Clog, which runs big and recommends sizing down. The Cozy also is explicitly not water resistant, so I would skip it for frequent damp-weather wear or anyone looking for a clog that can handle wet ground. Compared with The Revelvet, it offers clearer care and outsole information, but it is the least appealing choice if you want an unlined, simple open-back feel without added footbed softness.
Pros:- Contoured footbed combines arch support with vegan-shearling lining.
- Bouclé knit upper provides a textured alternative to the Casual Clog’s merino blend.
- Rubber outsole is described as offering traction indoors and outdoors.
- Machine washable, with thread made from recycled plastic bottles blended into the upper.
Cons:- Not water resistant, limiting its appeal in wet conditions.
- Roomy fit; shoppers between sizes are advised to size up.
- Requires air drying after washing.
Best for: Buyers who want a contoured, arch-supporting footbed with vegan-shearling lining and a rubber outsole for casual indoor-outdoor use in dry conditions.
Not ideal for: Anyone needing water resistance, preferring minimal lining, or uncertain about its roomy fit and size-up guidance between sizes.
- Style:Women’s pull-on slip-on clog
- Upper:Bouclé yarn blended with thread made from recycled plastic bottles
- Footbed:Contoured with arch support and vegan-shearling lining
- Sole material:Rubber
- Fit:Roomy; size up if between sizes
- Water resistance:Not water resistant
- Care:Machine wash; air dry
Our verdict“Choose The Cozy Clog over the Casual Clog when a lined, contoured footbed is your priority and you can accommodate its fit and dry-weather limits.”
Rothy’s Women’s The Revelvet Casual Clogs
The Revelvet Casual Clogs are the simplest match for someone who values an open-back shape and a roomy fit above a detailed care or traction specification. The open back makes slipping into the shoe straightforward, and its contoured footbed gives it a comfort-oriented feature without the added vegan-shearling lining found in The Cozy Clog. Its knit upper uses RWS-certified merino wool, a material distinction that separates it from the Cozy’s bouclé yarn blend.
Compared with The Casual Clog, Revelvet is less clearly pitched as an all-rounder: the Casual has a rubber outsole with stated indoor-outdoor traction, a cushioned insole, and machine-wash guidance. Revelvet’s listed sole and outer material are polyester, and the available details do not provide equivalent traction or cleaning instructions. That is not proof that it performs poorly, but it leaves buyers with less information for judging routine care and use outside the home. I would not assume it shares the washability or outsole behavior of the other two styles.
The roomy fit and open back may be helpful for shoppers who dislike a restrictive entry, but those same qualities can be a drawback if you want a close, secure-feeling fit. The product details do not include a sizing recommendation, so buyers should check the current size chart rather than importing the Casual Clog’s advice to size down or the Cozy’s advice to size up between sizes. I place Revelvet third because its shape and wool upper are appealingly distinct, yet the supplied specifications are thinner on practical use. It makes most sense when easy on-and-off wear is the deciding feature.
Pros:- Open-back design allows easy on-and-off wear.
- Roomy fit and contoured footbed suit shoppers seeking a relaxed clog shape.
- Knit upper uses RWS-certified merino wool.
- Offers a different material and silhouette emphasis from the lined Cozy Clog.
Cons:- Outer material and sole are listed as polyester, unlike the rubber soles of the other two picks.
- No washability or air-drying instructions are included in the supplied details.
- No explicit traction or water-resistance information is provided.
Best for: Shoppers who prioritize a roomy fit, an open back for easy entry, and a merino wool knit upper over detailed washability or traction guidance.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need explicit machine-wash instructions, stated indoor-outdoor traction, or fit guidance that resolves uncertainty about sizing.
- Design:Open-back casual clog
- Upper:Knit upper using RWS-certified merino wool
- Outer material:Polyester
- Sole material:Polyester
- Inner material:Merino wool
- Fit:Roomy
- Footbed:Contoured
- Lining:Fabric
- Origin:Imported
Our verdict“The Revelvet is the easiest-entry option here, but I would choose it only if its roomy open-back design matters more than the other models’ clearer care and outsole details.”
How We Picked
I compared these three Rothy’s styles against the needs implied by a clog purchase: an easy slip-on shape, dependable comfort cues, fit guidance, care requirements, and enough outsole information to judge whether a pair suits more than indoor wear. I gave the strongest overall position to The Casual Clog because its description combines a cushioned insole with arch support, lightweight construction, and a rubber outsole described as offering traction indoors and outdoors. Its recycled-plastic-bottle thread and machine-washable care add practical points, though its runs-big fit and air-dry-only instruction matter.
I placed The Cozy Clog next because its contoured, arch-supporting footbed and vegan-shearling lining make its comfort proposition distinct. Its rubber outsole also supports indoor-outdoor use, but the shoe is explicitly not water resistant, and its roomy fit has a different size recommendation from the Casual Clog. The Revelvet Casual Clog earns a place for its roomy fit, contoured footbed, merino wool knit upper, and open-back design. I ranked it third because the supplied details say less about traction, washability, and all-weather use, and list polyester for both its outer material and sole.
I did not assume that wool, a roomy fit, or a contoured footbed guarantees a particular level of warmth or support for every wearer. Nor did I fill gaps in the product information with claims about durability, water performance, or fit beyond the provided descriptions. My ranking favors the model with the clearest balance of comfort, care, and day-to-day versatility, then separates the other two by their more specialized strengths. Buyers should follow each style’s own fit advice and check current product details before ordering.
| Rothy’s clog | Style | Upper | Sole material | Fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rothy’s The Casual Clog Women’ | Platform slip-on mule clog | Merino wool and thread made from recycled plastic bottles | Rubber | Runs big; sizing down recommended |
| Rothy’s The Cozy Clog Women’s | Women’s pull-on slip-on clog | Bouclé yarn blended with thread made from recycled plastic bottles | Rubber | Roomy; size up if between sizes |
| Rothy’s Women’s The Revelvet C | — | Knit upper using RWS-certified merino wool | Polyester | Roomy |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Rothy’s Clogs
I would choose among these clogs by narrowing down the features that change daily wear: fit guidance, lining, sole information, and care. Their shared slip-on shape is only a starting point. The distinctions below matter more than small differences in styling if you want a pair that suits your routine.
Start with the fit instructions
These three shoes do not share a single sizing rule. The Casual Clog runs big, with the brand recommending that shoppers size down. The Cozy Clog has a roomy fit and advises people between sizes to size up. Revelvet is described as roomy, but the supplied details give no specific size adjustment. I would not apply one model’s recommendation to another, even though all three are Rothy’s clogs. Compare the brand’s current size guidance with your usual fit preferences, and take particular care if you sit between sizes. If you prefer a snug hold, an open-back or roomy style may feel less secure than you want; if you prefer space, that same shape may be an advantage.
Choose the footbed feel you want
The Casual Clog pairs a cushioned insole with arch support, which makes it the clearest choice for buyers who want those features without an explicitly shearling-lined footbed. The Cozy Clog has a contoured footbed with arch support and vegan-shearling lining, so it is the lineup’s softer-lined option. Revelvet also has a contoured footbed, but its description does not specify arch support or extra lining. I would avoid reading more into those terms than the descriptions say: a contoured footbed is not a guarantee that it will suit every foot, and the listed support features do not establish medical or orthopedic benefits. If your comfort needs are specific, focus on trying the correct fit where possible and use the product details as a comparison, not a promise.
Match materials and outsole details to your routine
The Casual and Cozy clogs both list a rubber outsole with indoor-outdoor traction, which gives them the clearest stated case for occasional wear outside as well as around the house. The Revelvet lists polyester for its sole and outer material, and its supplied details do not describe traction or water resistance. The Cozy is explicitly not water resistant, so it is not the one I would select for damp-weather use. No water-resistance claim is supplied for the other two, either; do not treat the absence of a warning as proof of waterproofing. Consider where you will wear the clogs and prioritize the models with a stated outsole purpose when traction information is important to you.
Think about washing and drying together
The Casual Clog and Cozy Clog are both described as machine washable, but each requires air drying. For the Casual, the instructions specify cold water and no heat during drying. That is useful if you value washable footwear, but it still takes planning before the pair is ready to wear again. The Revelvet’s supplied product details do not state whether it can be machine washed, so I would not assume it has the same care routine as the other two. If easy cleaning is a deciding factor, the first two have the clearer advantage; if you select Revelvet, check the current care directions before washing it.
Pick the silhouette that suits how you put shoes on
All three styles are slip-on clogs, but their shapes emphasize different things. The Casual is a platform slip-on mule, and its more defined platform styling may appeal to buyers who want a casual shoe with a little more visual presence. The Cozy has a pull-on shape with a lined footbed, making its softness the distinguishing detail. Revelvet has an open back and roomy fit, putting ease of entry first. If you need a close, secure fit, compare those shapes carefully; an open-back design is convenient, but it does not wrap around the heel. The best style is the one whose entry and fit match how you expect to wear it, not simply the one with the most inviting feature list.
Use the ranking as a shortcut, not a substitute for fit
I put The Casual Clog first because its listed features cover the broadest range of everyday needs: cushioning, arch support, a rubber outsole with stated traction, and machine-washable care. The Cozy comes next for buyers who place its vegan-shearling-lined footbed ahead of the Casual’s lighter construction, while accepting its non-water-resistant status and distinct sizing advice. Revelvet comes third because easy entry and a roomy fit are compelling for the right buyer, but the supplied specifications leave more unanswered questions about care and traction. If one of those specialized traits is your priority, choosing a lower-ranked option may still be the better personal match.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Rothy’s clog is the best all-around choice?
I rank The Casual Clog as the best all-around choice because its stated features combine a cushioned, arch-supporting insole, lightweight construction, machine-washable care, and a rubber outsole described for indoor and outdoor traction. Its main tradeoffs are the runs-big fit and air-dry-only care. If a soft vegan-shearling lining is more important to you than the broadest feature mix, The Cozy Clog may be a better personal choice.
How do the sizing recommendations differ?
The Casual Clog runs big, and the brand recommends sizing down. The Cozy Clog is roomy and advises shoppers between sizes to size up. Revelvet is also described as roomy, but the supplied details do not give a size-up or size-down recommendation. I would check each style’s current size chart independently rather than carrying sizing advice from one Rothy’s clog to another.
Which style has the softest stated footbed?
The Cozy Clog has the most explicitly soft-lined footbed in this comparison: it is contoured, includes arch support, and is lined with vegan shearling. The Casual Clog instead lists a cushioned insole with arch support, while Revelvet lists a contoured footbed without the same lining details. The descriptions distinguish their constructions, but personal comfort will depend on fit and preference.
Can I wear these clogs outside?
The Casual and Cozy clogs have rubber outsoles that are described as providing traction for indoor and outdoor wear. The Cozy is not water resistant, so that stated versatility does not make it a wet-weather shoe. Revelvet lists a polyester sole, but the supplied details do not specify traction or outdoor performance. I would use the listed information as a guide and avoid assuming any of these clogs are waterproof.
Are all three Rothy’s clogs machine washable?
The Casual Clog is machine washable in cold water and should air dry without heat. The Cozy Clog is also described as machine washable and air dry. The information supplied for Revelvet does not state that it is machine washable, so I would check its current care instructions before cleaning it. Even for the washable models, air drying means they are not ready immediately after a wash.
Conclusion
My recommendation depends on what you want from a clog. Choose The Casual Clog if you want the broadest mix of cushioning, arch support, stated indoor-outdoor traction, and washable care—and can follow its advice to size down and air dry. Pick The Cozy Clog if its contoured, vegan-shearling-lined footbed is your priority and you mostly wear clogs in dry conditions. Choose The Revelvet Casual Clog if an open back, roomy shape, and merino wool knit upper matter most, while recognizing that its supplied details say less about traction and cleaning. Across all three, fit guidance is style-specific, so I would verify the correct size for the exact model before ordering.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
